数学故事样稿
← 返回故事列表

mc1-067 · MATHEMATICS EXTENSION

几何的皇家大道The Royal Road to geometry

数学学习拓展 约 8 分钟阅读 中文English

内容概述

  • 数学故事
  • 数学史
  • 叙事

关于欧几里得的生平,仅有两个故事流传下来,且都未必可靠。据普洛克拉斯《欧德穆斯总结》记载,埃及王托勒密一世为表示对亚历山大博物馆的关心,曾师从欧几里得学习几何;因感到几何艰深,他询问是否有更易学的捷径,欧几里得答道:在几何中没有“皇家大道”。斯托比亚斯则将同一轶事安在梅内赫莫斯与亚历山大大王身上。作者最后指出,由于许多学生更擅长代数而非几何,用代数方法研究几何的“解析几何”,正是欧几里得认为不存在的“几何的皇家大道”。

中文正文

欧几里得的故事,只有两个流传下来,而且两个都可疑。普洛克拉斯(Proclus,410—485)在《欧德穆斯总结》中告诉我们,埃及王托勒密一世索特(Ptolemy Soter),亚历山大博物馆的创立者,为了表示对博物馆的关心,曾在欧几里得门下学几何。他发现那学科太难了。一天,他问老师,还有没有别的更容易的办法。欧几里得回答说:“哦,王爷,在现实世界里有两种路,普通百姓走的路和王爷走的路。但在几何里没有皇家大道。”

这个故事也被说成是别人的事情,斯托比亚斯(Stobaeus)讲的就是梅内赫莫斯(Menaechmus)在亚历山大大王身边的故事。

因为很多学生的代数能力远远强过他们的几何能力,于是,人们说以代数方法来研究几何问题的解析几何,就是欧几里得认为不存在的“几何的皇家大道”。

英文正文

DISAPPOINTINGLY little is known about the life and personality of Euclid except that he was the first professor of mathematics at the famed Museum of Alexandria (which opened its doors about 300 B.C.), and apparently the founder of the illustrious and long-lived Alexandrian School of Mathematics. Even his dates and his birthplace are not known, but it seems probable that he received his mathematical training in the Platonic school at Athens. Although he was the author of at least ten works, and fairly complete texts of five of these have come down to us, his reputation rests mainly on his Elements. As soon as this work appeared it was accorded the highest respect. No work, except the Bible, has been more widely used, edited, or studied, and probably no work has exercised greater influence on scientific thinking.

67° The royal road in geometry. Only two anecdotes about Euclid have come down to us, and both are doubtful. In his Eudemian Summary, Proclus (410–485) tells us that Ptolemy Soter, the first King of Egypt and the founder of the Alexandrian Museum, patronized the Museum by studying geometry there under Euclid. He found the subject difficult and one day asked his teacher if there weren't some easier way to learn the material. To this Euclid replied, “Oh King, in the real world there are two kinds of roads, roads for the common people to travel upon and roads reserved for the King to travel upon. In geometry there is no royal road.”

This is an example of an anecdote told also in relation to other people, for Stobaeus has narrated it in connection with Menaechmus when serving as instructor to Alexander the Great.

Since so many students are considerably more able as algebraists than as geometers, analytic geometry, which studies geometry with the aid of algebra, has been described as the “royal road in geometry” that Euclid thought did not exist.

相关题目

  • 题目:
  • 提示:
  • 解答或证明:

我们可以从故事中思考什么

  • 欧几里得为什么说“几何里没有皇家大道”?学习几何需要什么样的训练?
  • 解析几何为何被称为“几何的皇家大道”?它如何改变了人们研究几何问题的方式?
  • 流传至今的数学家轶事往往并不可靠,我们应当如何看待这类故事?

核心知识点讲解:解析几何

选择理由

故事以“几何的皇家大道”作结,点出解析几何正是用代数方法研究几何问题的道路,是贯穿本故事内核的知识点。

概念介绍

解析几何是借助坐标系与代数方程来研究几何图形性质的数学分支,它把几何问题转化为代数运算,把图形关系转化为方程关系。

具体内容

  1. 基本思想:在平面上建立直角坐标系,使点与有序数对、曲线与方程一一对应。
  2. 典型应用:用一次方程表示直线,用二次方程表示圆锥曲线。
  3. 历史意义:解析几何的创立,使人们能用代数技巧处理传统尺规作图与几何证明难以直接解决的问题。

应用场景

解析几何是微积分、线性代数、计算机图形学、物理学中描述运动轨迹与场分布的基础工具。

与生活的联系

导航地图中的路线计算、工程图纸的 CAD 建模、手机游戏中的碰撞检测,都依赖解析几何把空间关系转化为数值计算。

主要思想方法与延伸讨论

主要思想方法

  • 历史溯源:通过比较普洛克拉斯与斯托比亚斯的记载,辨析同一轶事在不同人物身上的版本差异。
  • 学科关联:看到代数能力与几何能力的不均衡,理解解析几何作为“桥梁”的价值。

延伸讨论

  • 解析几何与综合几何的关系:前者重计算与坐标,后者重逻辑与图形;两者相辅相成。
  • “皇家大道”的隐喻:在数学学习中,是否真的存在不经过艰苦训练就能掌握的捷径?